The Doors Open at Six on Black Friday: What OSHA's Exit Route Rules Ask of a Small Store's Crowd Plan
Black Friday crowds meet 29 CFR 1910.36 and 1910.37 at the door. What OSHA's exit route rules and crowd guidance mean for a small retailer's opening plan.
It is the Wednesday before Thanksgiving and you are walking the store after close. The doorbuster pallets came in this afternoon and the only open floor big enough to stage them is the wide aisle that runs from the registers to the back door. The flyer says doors open at six. Last year a line formed before five, and when the manager unlocked the front doors the first few dozen people came in faster than anyone expected. Nobody got hurt. You would like to keep it that way, and you are wondering whether there is anything more to it than "have enough staff on."
There is, and some of it is written into federal law. This post answers a narrow question: what OSHA's exit route standards, 29 CFR 1910.36 and 1910.37, require of a small store on its busiest morning, and how OSHA's own crowd management guidance for retailers fits around them. If you want the general case for an emergency plan, our post on what 1910.38 requires of an emergency action plan covers that. This one is about the doors, the aisles and the crowd.
Why OSHA has an opinion about your sale
OSHA does not regulate shoppers. It regulates the conditions your employees work in, and on a big sale morning the crowd is one of those conditions. OSHA's own news release on the subject describes the case that put this on its radar: in 2008, a worker was trampled to death when shoppers rushed through a store entrance at a post-Thanksgiving Black Friday sale. In the years after, OSHA sent letters to retail trade associations and fire officials ahead of the holiday season and published a fact sheet, Crowd Management Safety Guidelines for Retailers.
That fact sheet is guidance. It says plainly that it does not impose new compliance requirements. But OSHA's letter to retailers ties it to an obligation that is not optional: the duty under Section 5(a)(1) of the Occupational Safety and Health Act to provide a workplace free of recognized hazards that are causing or are likely to cause death or serious physical harm. A crowd surging through a door your employee has just unlocked is a hazard OSHA has publicly recognized for well over a decade. The guidance is the clearest statement available of what OSHA thinks a reasonable retailer does about it.
The exit route standards are different. They are specific, they apply on every day the store is open, and a big sale is simply the day they are most likely to be broken.
The pallet in the aisle: 1910.37(a)(3)
Start with the doorbuster pallets. 1910.37(a)(3) says exit routes must be free and unobstructed, and that no materials or equipment may be placed, either permanently or temporarily, within the exit route.
The word "temporarily" is the one that matters in November. Every store that blocks an exit aisle on a sale day intends to clear it later. The rule does not make an exception for the stock being there only until the morning rush, for the shrink-wrapped TVs that will be gone by eight, or for the overflow carts parked by the back door because there is nowhere else for them. If the aisle is part of the path from the sales floor to an exit, nothing goes in it.
The width rules reinforce this. 1910.36(g)(2) requires an exit access to be at least 28 inches wide at all points, and 1910.36(g)(4) says objects projecting into an exit route must not reduce its width below the minimum. Twenty-eight inches is a floor, not a target. On an ordinary Tuesday a narrow aisle might carry a handful of people. On Black Friday morning it may need to carry the whole front half of the store, which is where the capacity rule comes in.
How many people the building can actually let out: 1910.36(f)(1)
1910.36(f)(1) says exit routes must support the maximum permitted occupant load for each floor served. 1910.36(g)(3) adds that the width of an exit route must be sufficient to accommodate that maximum permitted occupant load.
For most small retailers, the maximum permitted occupant load is a number that already exists, usually set through the local building and fire code process, and sometimes posted on a placard near the entrance. Find out what yours is before the sale. If you do not know it, OSHA's fact sheet points to the right people: it recommends contacting local fire and police agencies to confirm the event site meets public safety requirements and that any permits are in place.
The link between these two rules is the one stores miss. Your exits were sized for your occupant load with the aisles clear. If the sale fills the floor to that number and the stockroom pallets have narrowed two aisles, the building is being asked to empty more people through less space than it was designed for. The fact sheet's recommendation follows directly: when the store reaches maximum occupancy, do not allow additional customers to enter until the occupancy level drops. Someone at the door needs to be counting, and needs the authority to stop the line.
Doors that open, from the inside, every time: 1910.36(d)
Stores think hard about doors on sale mornings, mostly about keeping them shut until opening time and controlling who comes in. That is fine for the outside. The inside is governed by 1910.36(d)(1): employees must be able to open an exit route door from the inside at all times without keys, tools or special knowledge. OSHA's guidance allows a device such as a panic bar that locks only from the outside on exit discharge doors.
Two habits break this rule during the holidays. The first is chaining or padlocking a side or rear exit to stop shoplifting while the floor is packed. The second is putting a single key-holder in charge of the back door, so that it opens only when that person is standing next to it. Both turn an exit into something that requires a key or a person, and both fail exactly when the store is fullest.
1910.36(d)(2) goes a step further and says exit route doors must be free of any device or alarm that could restrict emergency use of the route if the device or alarm fails. If you have added a lock, a bar or an alarm to an exit door for the season, ask what happens to that door when the device jams or loses power. If the answer is that the door stays shut, it does not belong on an exit.
OSHA's fact sheet says the same thing in plainer language under its heading for emergency situations: do not restrict egress, and do not block or lock exit doors.
The rest of OSHA's crowd guidance, applied to a small store
Big-box chains can put uniformed police at every entrance. A store with eight employees cannot, and the fact sheet does not pretend everyone can. Much of it scales down well.
Plan the line before customers arrive. The guidance recommends setting up barricades or rope lines well in advance, positioned so the customer line does not start right at the store entrance, with breaks and turns at regular intervals so that pressure from the back of the line does not travel straight to the front. A queue that runs along the storefront and turns the corner behaves very differently from one that presses flat against the glass.
Spread the crowd out. The fact sheet suggests numbered wristbands or tickets so that the earliest arrivals have their access to the limited items guaranteed without needing to run, and placing sale items in different parts of the store so that everyone is not heading for the same endcap. It also recommends keeping shopping carts and other potential obstacles inside, away from the entrance.
Decide who does what. The guidance calls for a staffing plan that assigns each worker a location, a designated manager who makes the calls during the event, and a designated person who contacts emergency responders if needed. It recommends telling every employee that the doors are about to open, using a separate entrance for staff, and positioning anyone managing the crowd to the side of the people coming in, never in the middle of their path. That last point is the one most directly connected to the 2008 case. The employee who unlocks the door should be able to step aside, not be standing in the doorway when it opens.
Train and rehearse. The fact sheet recommends training workers in the crowd plan and giving them a chance to practice it. For a small store, a fifteen-minute walk-through the night before, with every person standing where they will stand, is a practical version of that.
Have the emergency basics on hand. The guidance asks employers to know in advance who to call for emergency medical response, to have first-aid kits available, and to have AEDs available with staff trained in their use and in CPR. It also says employees should follow instructions from authorized first responders, regardless of company rules.
The night-before walk
None of this makes a store compliant on its own, and a store's obligations can also come from state plans and local fire codes that this post does not cover. But the night-before walk is where most of the exit route problems are found, because that is when the pallets, carts and extra displays are actually on the floor.
Walk every path from the sales floor to each exit and look for anything placed in it, however briefly it is meant to stay. Open each exit door from the inside, without a key, and check that nothing added for the season could stop it opening. Check that the exit routes are still lit well enough to see along, as 1910.37(b)(1) requires, after any lighting changes for the holiday displays, and that seasonal decorations have not been hung over exit doors in a way that obscures them, which 1910.37(b)(3) prohibits. Confirm who is counting at the door, what the occupancy number is, and who has the authority to hold the line.
If you can answer all of that before you lock up on Wednesday night, you have done most of what OSHA's rules and its guidance ask of you on the busiest morning of the year.
Related reading: The Door That Looks Like a Way Out: What OSHA 1910.37(b) Requires of Exit Signs | Emergency Lighting and Exit Routes | Workplace Violence Prevention in Retail
OSHA standards cited
- 29 CFR 1910.36
General Industry Standards
- 29 CFR 1910.37
General Industry Standards
- 29 CFR 1910.38
General Industry Standards
- OSH Act § 5(a)(1) — General Duty Clause
Employer obligation to furnish a workplace free of recognized hazards
Always verify current OSHA standards at osha.gov. This article reflects standards in effect at the date of publication.
Not sure where you stand?
Take the 5-minute compliance assessment. Answer a few questions about your business and get a prioritized list of what OSHA expects, free.
Related Articles
Continue learning about OSHA compliance and workplace safety
Emergency Planning
The Door That Looks Like a Way Out: What OSHA 1910.37(b) Requires of Exit Signs and 'Not an Exit' Marking
29 CFR 1910.37(b) sets rules for exit signs, directional signs and 'Not an Exit' marking. What a small business has to post, light and keep clear at each door.
Emergency Planning
The Alarm Nobody Ever Tested: What OSHA 1910.165 Actually Requires
OSHA 1910.165 governs how your crew learns to evacuate. Learn the two-month testing rule, the ambient noise standard, and the small-employer exception.
Emergency Planning
Who Needs an Emergency Action Plan, and What 1910.38 Requires It to Contain
Which employers 1910.38 applies to, when an oral plan is allowed instead of a written one, and the six elements the standard says every emergency action plan must contain.